Detection Assistant - Design Comparison

Select a design style to preview

Traditional card-based layout with clear hierarchy

Detection Assistant

Manuscript Quality Analysis Report

29
Total Checks
11
Passed
2
Warnings
16
Failed
Manuscript
Manuscript-related automated checks

Scope

Warning

Verifies whether the manuscript aligns with the journal's editorial scope.

Out of scope (if no pre-check decision, 1st decision is mandatory)

Potential Commercial Interests

Failed

Highlights potential undeclared financial ties or conflicts of interest in the manuscript.

Potential Commercial Interests detected

Controversial Topics

Passed

Flags sensitive subjects to ensure appropriate editorial oversight.

No controversial topics detected

Harmful Topics

Failed

Identifies content that may pose ethical or societal risks.

Harmful topics detected

Harmful Topics – Main Text

Passed

Identifies harmful content specifically within the main text.

No harmful content detected in main text

Template Phrase

Failed

Checks for leftover placeholder text to ensure the manuscript is ready for submission.

Undeleted template text found

Similar Title

Passed

Prevents duplicate submissions.

No similar title found

Similar Abstract

Failed

Monitors for potential self-duplication or redundant publication.

Duplicate abstract found in system

AI Generated Phrases

Failed

Highlights content patterns consistent with AI-generated text.

Suspected AI-generated phrases detected

Tortured Phrase

Failed

Flags unnatural phrasing that indicates automated rewriting.

Tortured phrases detected

Reference

Failed

Validates bibliography integrity.

Problematic references found

Publicly Available Data Set

Passed

Identifies mentions of open data repositories.

Public datasets mentioned

Zero Font Attacks

Failed

Detects hidden text attempts in manuscripts.

Hidden text detected

Author
Author identity, history, and compliance checks

Ethic Issue

Passed

Checks past records to identify authors with known ethical concerns.

No ethical issues found

Affiliation Watchlist

Failed

Verifies whether affiliation is recognized.

Affiliation not in whitelist ( Advanced Research Lab Global )

Author Blacklist

Passed

Checks if author is prohibited from submission.

Author not blacklisted

Doctoral Degree

Failed

Validates academic qualification of authors.

Not all authors have a Doctoral Degree

Suspect Employee

Passed

Checks if author identity matches MDPI staff.

No match with internal employee

Author User Name

Warning

Verifies submitted name matches account identity.

Submitted name does not match account profile - Johnal K. Doe <john.doe@email.com>

Author Watchlist

Passed

Flags authors on monitoring lists.

Author not on watchlist

Is North Korean

Passed

Ensures compliance with regional restrictions.

No restricted regional affiliation

Author Published Papers

Failed

Checks author’s publication volume.

High publication volume detected: 15 papers (≥ 12) this year

Author Submitted Papers

Failed

Monitors submission frequency.

High submission frequency detected: 8 manuscripts (≥ 6) in last 3 months

Author Affiliation Potential Interest

Failed

Highlights affiliation names suggesting commercial influence.

Potential commercial interest detected

Author Country Watchlist

Passed

Verifies compliance with sanctions lists.

Country not on sanctions list

Author Retraction

Failed

Checks external retraction history.

Retracted articles found

Review Report
Automated checks for reviewer reports

Sensitive Words

Failed

Ensures reviewer comments remain professional.

Sensitive language detected in review report.

Ethicality
Analyzes citation context to detect potential manipulation or relevance issues.

fileName_1.pdf

Failed

Potentially problematic references detected

fileName_2

Passed

Potentially problematic references detected